12
GAY PEOPLE'S CHRONICLE
Miami
Continued from page 1
Anti-gay groups, including the ones that campaigned for the amendment, argue that it should be interpreted broadly to include nearly all relationships other than marriage between one man and one woman.
Arizona group is backing the suit
The suit names president Garland as a defendant along with the school's board of trustees, all in their official capacities.
Brinkman is represented by the Alliance Defense Fund of Scottsdale, Arizona and the two attorneys who drafted the amendment, David Langdon and Jeffrey Shafer. At the time they wrote it, the two were law partners in Cincinnati.
Langdon is a familiar name in Ohio antigay lawsuits who shares the Sharonville address of Citizens for Community Values, which campaigned for the amendment. Shafer has since left to work in the Alliance Defense Fund's Washington, D.C. office.
ADF funds litigation around the nation to deny equality to gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender people, especially in marriage. It backed Cleveland Heights councilmember Jimmie Hicks this year in his unsuccessful suit against the city's domestic partner registry.
Assisting Langdon and Shafer are Langdon's new law partner Joshua Bolinger and ADF attorneys Benjamin Bull and Glen Lavy of Scottsdale.
Shafer is the lead attorney in the case and is being paid by ADF.
Langdon said ban won't affect benefits
During the amendment campaign on October 3, 2004, Langdon told the Associated Press that the amendment's second sentence would not rescind domestic partner benefits already offered by some public universities and cities, but it would stop others from doing so. At the time, Miami already offered them. This statement was consistent with the
December 2, 2005
amendment campaign's official message to the secretary of state and the public:
"Issue 1 does not interfere in any way with government benefits granted to persons in non-marital homosexual relationships, so long as the government does not grant those benefits to such persons specifically for the reason that the relationship is one that seeks to imitate marriage."
Shafer was asked what has changed to
Miami spends 0.2% of its $50 million benefits budget on employees' domestic partners.
make the amendment now affect the benefits. "I don't know what [Langdon] was thinking about with regard to the context of what he told the Associated Press," said Shafer. Langdon could not be reached for com-
ment.
Miami chosen because of location
Asked whether he approached ADF about the suit or they approached him, Brinkman described a mutual agreement that a suit needed to be filed and that he should be the plaintiff.
"I have known David Langdon for about ten years," said Brinkman. "We have meetings on issues, and things come up; those things happen and we decide who is to do what."
Brinkman said Miami was chosen among the five state schools with the benefits because of money and location.
His son and daughter attend Miami, and it is 45 minutes from his home.
Shafer said, "You have to start some place." According to Miami University spokes-
WHO'S WAITING FOR YOU?TM
Cleveland
216.626.1111
Columbus
LIVE
LOCAL
614.434.2323 MEN
Dayton
937.910.5222
Akron
330.572.1212
Cincinnati
513.766.7777
Find Your Number 1.800.777.8000
FREE TRIAL CODE: 6550
www.InteractiveMale.com
1.900.446.1212 ($1.99/min.) 18+
interactive male
person Richard Little, the school spends about $100,000 per year on the 33 or 34 domestic partners getting the benefits. This is 0.2% of Miami's $50 million benefits budget.
But Brinkman objects to it, saying that the school charged his daughter $35 just for a course syllabus.
"That's why I always vote against tuition caps," said Brinkman. “The schools always find ways to get more money anyway," inferring that he believes the $100,000 could be better spent.
Plaintiff has long anti-gay history
Brinkman, a Republican, has a long history of anti-gay activism. He was one of the principal organizers of Equal Rights Not Special Rights, the 1993 committee that passed the anti-gay Article 12 of Cincinnati's charter, repealed in 2004. He sued the city in 2003 in an attempt to block a hate crime law that included sexual orientation, and he was also a co-sponsor of the Ohio "defense of marriage act."
Brinkman also opposed fellow Republican Bob Taft's 1998 gubernatorial run because Taft selected pro-choice, pro-gay Jennette Bradley as his running mate.
Brinkman earned national notoriety two years ago when he was the only Ohio House member to vote against the state's ratification of the 14th Amendment, 135 years after it was added to the U.S. Constitution. The postCivil War amendment guarantees equality under the law to all citizens.
These positions and others often put Brinkman outside the mainstream of the Republican Party, and caused Ohio party chair Robert Bennett to declare in 2002, "Brinkman, in my opinion, is not a very intelligent human being.'
Brinkman is in his third House term and is not sure if he will run for re-election or for something else. He has also been eager to file lawsuits against the state as a legislator-a
rare move.
"Leaders should lead on issues important to them," said Brinkman.
Petro may have a political conflict
Ohio attorney general and Republican gubernatorial candidate Jim Petro is charged with defending the university in this suit.
In its defense, the university must either argue that the benefits don't approximate marriage and thus are not affected by the amendment, or that the amendment itself is unconstitutional.
It is not yet known which argument will be chosen. Both Petro's office and his gubernatorial campaign ignored numerous phone and e-mail requests for comment.
He has, however, according to Little, hired
Columbus attorney Kathleen Trafford of the firm Porter, Wright, Morris and Arthur to lead the university's defense. Trafford declined comment.
It will be Petro's decision on how far the case gets appealed if the university loses. This could politically rub against his gubernatorial campaign, his running mate, and his new position on marriage ban amendments.
Though Attorney General Petro opposed the marriage ban amendment when it was on the ballot as Issue 1 last year, candidate Petro favors the federal version pushed by President Bush.
"Jim Petro has always believed that marriage is between a man and a woman," says his campaign website. "Jim is opposed to same-sex marriage and supports the president's proposed constitutional amendment defining marriage as a union between a man and a woman."
Running mate is Brinkman ally
Petro's running mate is Hamilton County commissioner Phil Heimlich-a close personal and political ally of Brinkman.
Also an anti-gay activist, Heimlich and Brinkman have raised money and worked on each others' campaigns. They both have longstanding ties to Citizens for Community Values president Phil Burress, who is the source of most anti-gay activity in Ohio.
After endorsing Heimlich's candidacy in a special congressional election earlier this year, Brinkman waited for his friend to join Petro's ticket before getting in the race himself.
It is believed that Petro chose the social conservative Heimlich in order to be more competitive in the primary against Secretary of State Ken Blackwell, who is the favorite among Republican social conservatives.
Petro's vigorous defense of the university, particularly if they want to have the amendment declared unconstitutional, could be used by Blackwell against him.
Equality Cincinnati president Gary Wright attacked the suit, saying, "Regardless of the outcome of this suit, there is no alternative for repealing the ban on same-sex marriage that is now part of the Ohio Constitution."
"While it is not what they intended," said Wright, "the people pursuing this suit are helping to show Ohioans what their real motives are and why this amendment is so wrong for everyone in this state. Their purpose is not to protect anyone's marriage."
The case has been assigned to Judge Charles L. Pater.
The university's answer to the complaint is due December 20.
Shafer said he expects that with appeals, the case will likely take two years to conclude.
KRAVE
NITECLUB KRAVENITECLUB.COM
T
12/3/05 Cyndi Lauper OFFICIAL
AFTER CONCERT
PARTY!
2000 Sycamore St. Power House Lower Level Next to Shark Club 216.443.9556
Non4Men Connect
Record, Listen & Respond to personal ads
Free!
(code: 3399)
voice MALE
THE CONFIDENTIAL CONNECTION
Cleveland 216-621-4222
Fon-330-376-7733 Toledo 419-242-3999 Dayton 937-22743525
+Only! Origis Commons :: 1-800-825-1538
Browse, Match, Chat. try it FREE!
code: 9911
216-575-7656
18+ Only! Origin Communications, Inc:: 1-800-825-